5406 Marina Drive
Holmes Beach, FL 34217

Feast on Rich Coconut Key Lime Cake or Pie

The Feast’s Coconut Key Lime Pie is a Piece of Cake

Introduction to Key Lime Pie in Sarasota

When it comes to iconic American desserts, Key lime pie stands out with its tangy and sweet flavor profile. Originating from the Florida Keys, this dessert has a rich history and a loyal following. If you find yourself in Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island, the quest for the best Key lime pie is a culinary adventure worth undertaking. One place that stands out is The Feast Restaurant, renowned for transforming this classic dessert into their unique Coconut Key Lime Cake. Let’s explore the history of Key lime pie and discover how The Feast Restaurant brings a tropical twist to this beloved treat.

The Origins of Key Lime Pie

The Birth of a Floridian Classic

Key lime pie, with its zesty and creamy texture, can trace its origins back to the late 1800s in the Florida Keys. Early settlers, particularly those migrating from the Bahamas, utilized the local Key limes to create this dessert. Key limes, smaller and more aromatic than the common Persian lime, were a staple in South Florida. The pie’s filling, a combination of condensed milk, egg yolks, and Key lime juice, was a practical creation given the scarcity of fresh milk before modern refrigeration. This simplicity and the unique flavor of the limes quickly made Key lime pie a favorite among locals.

Evolution from Magic Lemon Cream Pie

Interestingly, the evolution of Key lime pie may have been influenced by a similar dessert known as the Magic Lemon Cream Pie. This dessert appeared in a 1931 promotional brochure by Borden, a condensed milk producer. The recipe included condensed milk, lemon juice, lemon rind, and egg yolks. Over time, local cooks in the Florida Keys substituted lemons with the more readily available Key limes, giving rise to the distinct Key lime pie we know today.

Key Lime Pie in Manatee County: Where to Find the Best

The Charm of The Feast Restaurant

Located in the heart of Holmes Beach, The Feast Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone seeking the best Key lime pie in Sarasota. This family-owned establishment has been delighting diners since 2009 with its fresh, local, and exotic cuisine. Their version of Key lime pie comes traditionally and in the form of a Coconut Key Lime Cake, a delightful fusion that captures the essence of tropical flavors.

The Feast Restaurant’s Coconut Key Lime Cake

A Tropical Delight

The Feast Restaurant’s Coconut Key Lime Cake is a masterpiece that takes their classic Key lime pie to new heights. This dessert marries the tangy zest of Key limes with the rich, nutty flavor of coconut, creating a symphony of tastes that transport you to sun-drenched beaches and swaying palm trees. Each bite is a journey through the tropics, a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to capturing the spirit of island living.

Crafting a Unique Culinary Experience

The Feast Restaurant prides itself on crafting desserts that are not only delicious but also reflective of the local culture and ingredients. Their Coconut Key Lime Cake is a perfect example of this philosophy. Using fresh Key limes and quality coconut, the restaurant creates a dessert that is both familiar and innovative. It’s a dish that exemplifies the creativity and culinary expertise that The Feast Restaurant is known for.

Exploring the Best Key Lime Pie on Holmes Beach

A Taste of Tradition and Innovation

Holmes Beach, part of Anna Maria Island, offers a charming backdrop for savoring the best Key lime pie. While traditional Key lime pie is available and delicious, it’s the innovative twist like The Feast Restaurant’s Coconut Key Lime Cake that truly stand out. These unique takes on the classic dessert highlight the versatility and enduring appeal of Key limes as a key ingredient.

What Makes Key Lime Pie Special

The distinctive flavor of Key lime pie comes from the Key limes themselves. These limes are smaller and more aromatic than the common Persian lime, with a distinctive yellow juice that adds a unique tanginess to the pie. Combined with the creamy texture of condensed milk and the richness of egg yolks, the pie offers a balanced sweetness and tartness that is hard to resist.

A Sweet Conclusion: Savoring the Best Key Lime Pie

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, indulging in Key lime pie in Sarasota and Holmes Beach is a must. The rich history of this dessert, coupled with innovative takes like The Feast Restaurant’s Coconut Key Lime Cake, offers a delightful culinary experience. As you explore these coastal areas, be sure to make a stop at The Feast Restaurant to savor their unique twist on this classic dessert. Pair it with a sparkling wine for a real treat

External Links

For further insights into the history of Key lime pie and The Feast Restaurant’s culinary delights, these links provide a wealth of information. Enjoy your journey through the flavors of Key lime pie and the tropical charm of Coconut Key Lime Cake! 🍰🌴🥥

More from The Feast

Pork potstickers

Pork Potstickers: Savor the Flavor

Potstickers, also known as guotie in Mandarin, have delighted taste buds for centuries. These crispy-bottomed…

Read More
Margherita pizza basil topped

Margherita Pizza at The Feast – DELIZIOSA

In this article, we’ll delve into the heavenly use of basil on pizzas, tracing its…

Read More

Grouper Bites Are a Must-Try in Florida

From ancient times to modern kitchens, grouper has been a cherished part of Florida’s diet…

Read More


This is an accessibility statement from Feast Restaurant

URL: https://thefeastrestaurantami.com/

Feast Restaurant is committed to ensuring digital accessibility for people with disabilities. We are continually improving the user experience for everyone, and applying the relevant accessibility standards.

Efforts to support accessibility

Hurricane Liquors takes the following measures to ensure accessibility:
  • Accessibility is part of our mission statement.
  • Accessibility is part of our internal policies.
  • Clear accessibility targets and responsibilities exist within the organization.
  • Formal accessibility quality assurance methods exist within the organization

Conformance status

Current accessibility standard of the site:
WCAG 2.1 level AA
Current content conformance status:
Fully conformant: the content fully conforms to the accessibility standard without any exceptions.
Compatibility with browsers and assistive technology
This site is designed to be compatible with the following browsers:
  • chrome
  • internet explorer
  • firefox
Accessibility of this site relies on the following technologies to work:
  • HTML
  • CSS
  • SMIL
Assessment methods
Feast Restaurant assessed the accessibility of this site using the following method(s): Self-evaluation: the site was evaluated internally by the company or organization.
Feedback process
We welcome your feedback on the accessibility of this site. Please contact us via one of the following methods:

Phone: +12 34 56 89

  • E-mail: accessibility@example.org
  • Postal Address: 1 Example Street, Suburb, Country, Postcode
We aim to respond to feedback within 7 business days.


This Privacy Policy explains how FEAST RESTAURANT (“we”, “us”, or “our”) collects, uses, and discloses your personal information when you use our website, hurricanehanks.com (“Site”), and when you interact with us as a customer of our restaurant. We are committed to protecting the privacy of our customers and ensuring the security of their personal information. By using our Site or our restaurant, you agree to the terms of this Privacy Policy.

Information We Collect

We collect information that you provide to us, such as your name, email address, telephone number, and credit card information when you make a reservation or place an order through our Site or in-person. We may also collect information from you through our loyalty program, social media pages, and surveys.

We may also collect information about your device and your usage of our Site, such as your IP address, browser type, and pages visited.

Use of Information

We use the information we collect to:

  • Fulfill your reservations and orders and provide customer support
  • Improve our products and services
  • Communicate with you about promotions and updates
  • Personalize your experience with our restaurant and Site

Comply with legal obligations

We may use third-party service providers to assist us in these activities, such as payment processors, email service providers, and website analytics providers.

Disclosure of Information

We may disclose your personal information to:
Service providers who assist us in providing our products and services
Law enforcement or other government officials as required by law
Other third parties with your consent
We do not sell or rent your personal information to third parties for their marketing purposes.

Data Security

We take reasonable measures to protect the security of your personal information, including using encryption technology to transmit sensitive data.

Children’s Privacy

Our Site and restaurant are not intended for children under the age of 13. We do not knowingly collect personal information from children under the age of 13 without parental consent.

Changes to this Privacy Policy

We may update this Privacy Policy from time to time. We will post any changes on this page and, if the changes are significant, we will provide a more prominent notice. You should check this page periodically to review any changes.

Contact Us

If you have any questions about this Privacy Policy or our privacy practices, you may contact us at info@thefeastrestaurantami.com


Last updated February 06, 2023

Website Disclaimer

The information provided on our menu, website [ https://thefeastrestaurantami.com/], or any other promotional material is for general informational purposes only. We make every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information, however, we cannot guarantee that all information is up to date and free from errors. Prices and availability of menu items may be subject to change without notice. In addition, we cannot guarantee that our menu items are free from allergens or cross-contamination. Please inform your server of any food allergies or dietary restrictions prior to ordering. Thank you for dining with us.

Testimonials Disclaimer

The Site may contain testimonials by users of our products and/or services. These testimonials reflect the real-life experiences and opinions of such users. However, the experiences are personal to those particular users, and may not necessarily be representative of all users of our products and/or services. We do not claim, and you should not assume, that all users will have the same experiences. YOUR INDIVIDUAL RESULTS MAY VARY. The Site may contain testimonials by users of our products and/or services. These testimonials reflect the real-life experiences and opinions of such users. However, the experiences are personal to those particular users, and may not necessarily be representative of all users of our products and/or services. We do not claim, and you should not assume, that all users will have the same experiences. YOUR INDIVIDUAL RESULTS MAY VARY.
Testimonials on our website or social media pages are provided by our customers voluntarily and are their personal opinions. We do not claim or guarantee that these testimonials are representative of everyone’s experience with our restaurant. Results may vary based on individual preferences and experiences. We appreciate all feedback and strive to provide excellent service to all of our customers.